Musical instruments are heresy ..... say what?

Discussions on ecclesiology such as the nature, constitution and functions of the church.
Post Reply
User avatar
Established Member
Posts: 197
Joined: Sun May 08, 2016 10:36 pm
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Undecided
Has liked: 45 times
Been liked: 20 times

Musical instruments are heresy ..... say what?


Post by JButler » Thu Sep 22, 2016 1:08 pm

I wasn't sure if I should tack this onto the other music related thread but it seemed to require a thread of it's own for discussion. The more I read and thought, the more I felt compelled to post this.

Years ago I read that Calvin had banished all music from worship services, based on as I understand it, to preserve the purity of worship. But later on he changed his mind and allowed congregational singing but no instrumentation. I didn't spend any time researching it being pre-internet IIRC. While perusing the forum today the other thread headline prompted this thought and I decided to actually look into it.

Bluntly speaking I'm not sure what I learned but I'm really scratching my head about what I read.

I did not expect to see Calvin/Calvinist theologians claim that musical instruments in worship were heresy!

The full quote is in the above link but this one jumped out....
"We are to remember that the worship of God was never understood to consist in such outward services, which were only necessary to help forward a people as yet weak and rude in knowledge in the spiritual worship of God. -"
I'm confused, does this mean King David was weak and rude in knowledge about how to worship?? How do you sing a psalm without knowing the cadence and such?

Reading through (or trying) the writings/quotations I kind of see a theme emerging. They have an intense hatred toward the Pope and all things related, including organ music. I understand why that is. So in the pursuit of "purity" they throw out everything connected to the RCC. In essence...they throw the baby out with the bath water or rather, throw the organ out with the church.

What Scripture passage(s) are they basing these ideas upon? I noted the lack of Scriptural citations in the linked site. Usually when someone is making a theological point they anchor it with at least one Scripture, even if they twist it's meaning.

There's a lot more about what I'm reading that really baffles me, actually it seems bizarre. Maybe I'm off plumb or am not seeing their statements through the correct filters. But I've around the law for decades and fairly good at sorting out complex sentences so I think I've a good handle on what they said, its just the why and how they back up their statements that stumps me.

I am so thankful that God is opening my eyes to the Scriptures and giving me discernment to sort through Scripture vs statements of people. I'm still a baby but already see things amazing & profound, but at the same time seeing some very disturbing things also.

In the past I would have never sought to learn more about a topic like this, since in Dutch Reformed you learn not to question or worse, argue a different view.
If the truth hurts, maybe it should.

Ultimate Member
Posts: 4944
Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2014 4:31 am
Christian: Yes
Sex: Male
Creation Position: Gap Theory
Has liked: 203 times
Been liked: 168 times

Re: Musical instruments are heresy ..... say what?


Post by abelcainsbrother » Sat Sep 24, 2016 4:09 am

It is good that you are learning and God is opening your eyes to the scriptures and giving you discernment to sort through scripture vs statements of people and you are correct in your discernment about Calvin being wrong about musical instruments and praise and worship.

Dancing With The Ark. For you
Hebrews 12:2-3 Looking unto Jesus the author and finisher of our faith;who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross,despising the shame,and is set down at the right hand of the throne of God.

2nd Corinthians 4:4 In whom the god of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not,lest the light of this glorious gospel of Christ,who is the image of God,should shine unto them.

Post Reply